Skip to content
Madison AveNew

A new publication, since 2026.

Screening Room No. 002

Metro Trains Melbourne, “Dumb Ways to Die” (2012)

What does “fewer near misses” mean when the operator itself says it is too early to tell?

A train-safety campaign gets judged on one question. Did trains get safer? The record gives two numbers for Dumb Ways to Die, and neither one answers it cleanly.

McCann Melbourne made the film for Metro Trains Melbourne, and it came out in November 2012, and the film’s own channel timestamps the upload 14 November that year, in US Pacific time, while the brief, as the WARC case summary states it, was to “get young people to care about being safe around trains.” The campaign won a Gold Lion at Cannes in 2013, in Brand Experience and Activation. No songwriter, director or animator is named here, because none of those credits is confirmed on a page we read. Secondary accounts suggest the film carries its message in a song and not a warning. That is an inference, and nothing we could read says whether the method worked.

Thirty per cent, in three months

In February 2013 Metro’s corporate relations manager, Leah Waymark, told The Age that near misses had fallen by “more than 30 per cent” between November and January, compared with 2011/12, a figure we read through a Safetyrisk post of 14 February 2013 and not through The Age itself. The same remark carries its own hedge, in her words: “it’s too early to be confident of a sustainable reduction in near misses, the early signs are encouraging.”

A claim, then, over a three-month window. The operator attached the caveat.

Twenty-one, a few years on

A 2016 LAist article says officials noted “a 21 percent decrease in rail accidents and near misses” but could not “attribute it solely to the video,” and the record does not show that this figure and the 30 per cent one measure the same thing over the same period. That is not a trend. This entry does not treat it as one.

Other figures circulate, among them views, game downloads and a later rise in near misses. We found them only in search summaries and print none of them.

Watch it on the Dumb Ways to Die channel, which carries the film and a verified badge.

Madison AveNew