Dead Men Talking
Harry Webber’s column of June 8, 2005, told briefly. His own page is linked below.
The file is called mad40, but the column inside calls itself Volume Thirty-Eight, dated Wednesday, June 8, 2005. By then Harry Webber had read the same complaint in Ad Age, the New York Times, AdRants and Adweek, and he boiled it down to one line: “Advertising doesn’t work as well as it used to, but costs more than it ever did.”
He didn’t argue with it. He quoted the author of Ageless Marketing, David B. Wolfe (Harry spells him Wolf), on marketing as the only part of a business where productivity falls while costs rise, and then he asked the next question. Where would the money go instead?
He went down the answers the trade press was offering in 2005, one at a time, and turned each of them away in a line or two. Direct mail, banners, branded entertainment, buzz, viral, advergames, product placement, radio, outdoor, search and eBay all went. Then he played a chief marketing officer holding $500 million with nowhere left to spend it, who parks it in price support and likes how the year to date looks.
His own answer was to stop buying ads at all. “Zero Ad Waste. Zero Advertising.” He pictured American Express’s chief marketing officer, John Hayes, telling NBC Universal’s Bob Wright that the company would spend six million dollars a week on a network show that made life better for viewers, and pay half the production cost. Then Hayes would dare other marketers to put up a million a week each on CBS, under the name Step Up America.
The question he left open
He didn’t claim it would work. He asked whether anyone would step up, whether people would watch, and whether CBS would even be interested, and he asked readers to email him with what they thought.
The email address he gave is twenty years old. The column is linked below as the Internet Archive caught it in July 2005, and the rest of his issues are in the index of his original issues.
The original: Dead Men Talking, captured July 29, 2005 by the Internet Archive.